ComScore

This Morgan Freeman Drama Is So Good It Should've Been the One to Get Him His First Oscar

I'm sticking by this

morgan-freeman-shawshank-redemption-mobile
Castle Rock Entertainment/Getty Images

Morgan Freeman should have won an Academy Award for The Shawshank Redemption, and I will forever stand by that.

A gripping movie that will have you tearing up, the film tells the story of a man named Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins), who is falsely accused and convicted for the murders of his wife and her lover, and sentenced to two consecutive life terms in prison. Obviously, when you’re faced with the plight of being falsely convicted of a crime and the harsh reality that you’re going to have to spend the rest of your life in prison, your life seems like it’s, well, over. Naturally, the overwhelming sense of depression that follows Andy is tough to deal with, and there is only one saving grace for him during this time period: a friendly gentleman known simply as Red (Freeman), who ends up becoming his mentor.

Red, himself, is a contraband smuggler serving a life sentence, and the two immediately form a heartwarming friendship. Red is there to support Andy at the beginning of his prison sentence when he is struggling to adapt to his new life. The two of them take on a mentorship role with the younger Tommy Williams (Gil Bellows), helping him pass his GED. Red is there to lift Andy up after the disappointment of being thrown into solitary confinement. Simply put, Red is the true friend that everybody deserves to have within their lifetimes.

Freeman’s subtle-yet-powerful performance and narration is part of what makes Shawshank so great. The direct, no-nonsense personality he gives Red balances out Andy’s glass-half-full mentality that at times seems way beyond the point of being realistic. Red is the Yin to Andy’s Yang and never leaves his side. And while Red may not see Andy’s vision at first, he also never doubts him (I won’t spoil the surprise ending).

Don’t get me wrong, The Shawshank Redemption did receive its recognition at the 1995 Academy Awards with seven nominations, which also included a “Best Actor” nomination for Freeman, but the film was shut out completely. Yes, The Shawshank Redemption didn't win a single Academy Award despite it now being recognized as one of the most beloved films in cinematic history. As for Freeman, I consider the 1995 “Best Actor” category to be among the toughest of the decade. Aside from Freeman's performance, you had Tom Hanks (who wound up winning) for Forrest Gump, Nigel Hawthorne for The Madness of King George, John Travolta for Pulp Fiction and Paul Newman for Nobody's Fool all up for contention. 

morgan-freeman-shawshank-redemption-shawshank-2
Castle Rock Entertainment/Getty Images

Most people (myself included), have this category narrowed down to Hanks and Freeman, and while it is a tough call, I’m going with Freeman, but with a plot twist of my own—I don’t believe Freeman should have even been put in the “Best Actor” category to begin with. Sure, if you get technical, his performance applies to that category because he is the narrator and the story is told from his character’s perspective, but, Red’s character is what would typically be classified as a supporting role in almost any other circumstance. Therefore, I believe Freeman should have been nominated for “Best Supporting Actor,” and I believe he should have won that category.

Is this a copout? Perhaps, but I can’t disregard the impact of Tom Hanks’ portrayal of Forrest Gump, and what it has meant to popular culture either in the decades since. If they had put Freeman in the “Best Supporting Actor” category, both would have walked out with Oscars, which would have made the ceremony even more monumental in hindsight considering what Shawshank has evolved into as far as its cultural significance.

Nonetheless, both Freeman and Robbins (who was overlooked for a nomination period) for that matter were brilliant, and if you haven’t watched The Shawshank Redemption, I highly recommend doing so.

You stream The Shawshank Redemption via Prime Video.




Screenshot 2024 03 04 at 4.32.14 PM

Associate Commerce Strategist

  • Covers all things commerce and entertainment
  • Has over a decade of editorial experience in both fashion and entertainment, and was previously with ONE37pm before joining the PureWow team in March 2024
  • Studied journalism and marketing at Columbus State University in Georgia

OSZAR »